> Fifteen Tips for Muslim Men talking about "Women in Islam"

[Aayah]

I read this article today and found it very interesting.


Fifteen Tips for Muslim Men talking about "Women in Islam"
Guidance for Muslim men on how to deal effectively with the stereotypes and misperceptions about women in Islam.

Sadly, some Muslim men make the problem of outsiders' perception of women in Islam worse without realizing it, instead of clarifying the issue. This is rarely, if ever, done intentionally. However, what’s clear is that some guidelines are necessary for brothers when talking about the issue of women in Islam. Here are some suggested tips:

1. Let the sisters speak

No matter how well-spoken, eloquent or intelligent a brother is, the bottom line is this: he is not a Muslim woman.

That means no matter how much you, as a Muslim man tell a non-Muslim woman how wonderful hijab is, it will be harder for her to accept this because you have never worn Hijab and you are not a woman.

Whenever possible, have sisters answer questions pertaining to Islam and women.

2. Be careful of mixing up the ideal with the reality

One non-Muslim writer once remarked how when talking to Muslims about Islam compared to the West, Muslims take the ideal of Islam and compare it to the reality of the West.

The fact of the matter is there are very ugly realities when it comes to the treatment of women in many parts of the world, including the Muslim world. Muslims must recognize the reality of domestic violence in the community, even though Islamic ideals would never condone such ugly behavior.

3. Don’t sacrifice speaking out against injustice in the name of protecting Islam’s "image"

"Tackle the issue and the image will take care of itself," advises Sr. Kathy Bullock, a convert to Islam based in California. Don’t fall into the tendency to ignore pressing issues for the sake of protecting Islam’s reputation.

In other words, if someone brings up the issue of honor killing in Jordan, acknowledge the reality but make it clear that this is a sin and a crime in Islam and as a Muslim you condemn it. This in itself is enough. Trying to justify or make excuses for it or covering it up is not going to score image points for Islam.

4. Don’t respond to unspoken accusations

A number of times, Muslims automatically start an apologetic tirade defending the status of women in Islam before a person has even said a word. Let the other person initiate questions, and answer calmly and confidently. You may be responding to an accusation that was never even in the person’s mind in the first place.

5. Ask WHY

Do this before launching an apologetic tirade against any accusation. For instance, a man in Spain once approached a scholar, saying he felt Islam was a man’s religion. Before rebutting him, the scholar asked him why he thought this way. The man replied that whenever he looked at mosques, he saw only men.

By knowing why, you can develop your answer accordingly, and tackle the issue head-on in an honest and direct way.

6. Agree with people as much as possible

Start off agreeing with a person. It will completely turn the tables on the discussion, as many people begin discussions on women in Islam assuming Muslims are completely against the notion of women’s rights.

7. If you don’t know something SAY SO

If a person tells you they’re from X country you’ve never heard of and Muslim women are treated in a horrible fashion what can you say about it?

I have never heard of that, and I don’t know are simple enough. Don’t start apologizing, or denying that it happens. Tell the truth.

8. Don’t be condescending

In Islam, looking down on a fellow human being is a sin, whether the person is a male or a female. Don’t think you know all there is to know about women in Islam, and don’t speak in this manner either. Allah does not love arrogance, and only Allah has full knowledge of all things.

9. Don’t interrupt

This is a problem in a number of cultures, men interrupting women and other men when they speak. Not only is this rude behavior, it takes away from your message. People are less likely to listen to you if you come across as a rude boorish individual. Don’t do this to others, especially sisters.

10. Don’t assume all Muslim sisters are the same

Just because your mom, who was born and brought up in a Muslim country, and has never had a problem with hijab does not mean that other Muslim sisters have the same experience.

Muslim sisters are as different as brothers, as are their experiences with issues like hijab.

11. Become more attuned to the "new Muslim woman"

Muslim sisters today are not the same as those of yesterday. Many Muslims sisters know more, and they prefer more interactive lectures as opposed to the passive style normally used. If you’re giving a talk, be ready to have interjections from Muslim sisters. Welcome these, don’t shun them.

12. Choose your words very carefully

If you’re doing a presentation on women’s issues in Islam or responding to a basic question, make sure to choose your words extremely carefully. Know the exact dictionary meaning, as well as the meaning in everyday usage. Words are extremely powerful, and they leave an imprint on the hearts and minds of people. You want that imprint to be positive, so be careful.

13. Actions speak louder than words

You can speak beautifully about women in Islam on behalf of the Muslim Students’ Association (MSA), but if throughout the year, sisters have been denied access to the prayer room, or the right to participate in decision-making in the MSA, then think of how silly your talk is.Make sure your personal and organizational behavior falls in line with your words.

14. Don’t stereotype all Western women

"Table dancers" or "cheerleaders" is how one Muslim sister described the way Muslims tend to stereotype all Western women. Let’s not forget: we hate it when Muslim women are stereotyped as oppressed, so we should not be doing the same to others.

And lest we forget, a growing number of Western women are becoming our Muslim sisters, and very practicing ones at that.

15. Seek women’s perspective on issues

You know mom, who loves you so much and makes your dinner? She’s a woman. Your sister in school? She’s a woman. If you’re blessed to be surrounded by practicing Muslim sisters in your home, take advantage of this by seeking their views on issues like hijab, domestic violence, community participation, and media stereotypes. There’s nothing like hearing the truth presented from those who truly live it.

Source

[salman]

sisters in mix MSA, a big fat NO. I have seen what goes around in my university MSA, maybe not regularly but at least during big events (e.g., end of term dinner, etc.). It is nothing but fitnah and we just ignore as if they are small things so let's be 'cool' about it.

Jazak Allah khayr for sharing; some of them are good.

[Umm Marwa Mustafa]

1. Let the sisters speak

No matter how well-spoken, eloquent or intelligent a brother is, the bottom line is this: he is not a Muslim woman.

So what? Since when does it become necessary to be a woman in order to talk about issues that pertain to women. This article starts off with a lame point, boo.

[Aayah]

^ because no one can know how women feel but women themselves!
Of course men can do great job when talking about women, but it become more effective when women talk about thereselves!

[salman]

^ukht, your point is well noted but it is not always true. And that is what sister Ruwayda is trying to say. Remember the context here, we are talking about speaking about issues related to women to others (non-Muslims specifically). Sometime a brother can convey the message better about women issues maybe due to his knowledge, better speech and articulation, etc. and I would even argue that there is not 100% possibility of women knowing themselves well or being able to articulate the issues well. Generally speaking, yes the women's speech about their issues can be more effective. However, not always the case.

Edit

after reading your point again, subhaanAllah, it seems we all are talking about the same thing but only lafzi difference here.

[Aayah]

^ Maybe not in all cases, maybe according to the speaker knowledge but still, from what I experienced in other forums, I remembered once we were talking about women issues and there was no indication for genders in that forum so no one know whether I am brother or sister, some members in that forum "which was not Islmaic one" attacked me of being extremist one talking about hijab issue and free mixing in work. After they knew that I am a sister not brother.....they took back their words and apologized seeing that women of Islam are the ones who defend their religion and Shari'ah and fully convinced with it!

[Umm Marwa Mustafa]

So they *only* accepted your arguments simply because you were a woman? That doesn't sound right.

if your argument is sound it will work regardless of gender.

[Ibn Ilyas]

Assalamu Aleykum ww

To the sister above: I think she meant more like "strengthened" "reinforced" her arguements in that particular case because she was a woman...

[Umm Marwa Mustafa]

Originally Posted by Ibn Ilyas

Assalamu Aleykum ww

To the sister above: I think she meant more like "strengthened" "reinforced" her arguements in that particular case because she was a woman...

That makes no sense. Freemixing is something that relates to men and women, likewise Hijab. Point being, If arguments are sound, gender plays little if no role. (In my opinions).

Fe Aman llah.

[Raied]

Good points sister.