> Muslim Response Ali Sina: Why I left Islam

[salamfromrom]

Salam bro

About the slave killing incident, if I remember correctly, I read an explanation on that and it was explained that the woman was killed because she was a non-muslim who was governed by the treaty between the muslims/kufar which stipulated that they had to fight against the enemy together, help eachother etc and the contract also stipulated that Muhammad(pbuh) was not to be degraded etc. That's why Muhammad(pbuh) didn't punish her killer, because she broke the covenant and was liable for punishment anyways. The Prophet(pbuh) was always ready to forgive (the jewess poisoning his food incident and many others) but since the muslim had already killed the kafir woman , there was no need to punish him although from the explanation I read it can be deducted that Muhammad(pbuh) was of the opinion that it might have been preferrable for the muslim to overlook the woman's slurs.

I don't know how that would apply these days seeing as how we don't have an agreement like that between the islamic ruler and the dhimmi.

(Im not sure if the above is exactly right, but I think it definately might be. too bad I don't remember exactly where I heard that explanation from.)
I hope someone with greater knowledge can better explain if this is correct.
Salam

[amar_labedi]

From a very long time i was wondering how there is no one to care for the refutation against Islam but Alhamdulillah here i notice that there is someone who can check the rubbish and silly actions of Ali Sena

O Allah! Guide us to your straight path! The path of those who have your blessing, not those who qualify themselves for your punishment and nor those who are astray!
================================================== ======

[Umm Sufyaan]

apostates are scum, honestly. they go around spread bs about Islam to justify their hate for it. they need a justification and a clear conciseness for their the sin they commit knowingly and intentionally so being the immature pieces of rubbish they are, they shift the blame.

[amar_labedi]

Assalamalaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu

You are right brother The way he challenges is really disturbing may fall prey to his lunatic expressions.

O Allah! Guide us to your straight path! The path of those who have your blessing, not those who qualify themselves for your punishment and nor those who are astray!
================================================== ======

[Sensationnz]

Salamalikum

akhi u might as well send this to Contactus@faithfreedom.com , it run by a muslim, who is answering ali sina and faithfreedom of apostates.

here is his website. Faithfreedom.com - exposing the lies and vile propaganda behind ***************** and secularislam.org

Wsallam

[amar_labedi]

Assalamalaikum wa rahamatullahi wa barakatuhu

You have clearly clarified Ali Sina's assumption and ideology . Though countless Islamic personalities are there all around why don't they respond to him and his challenge.

He clearly challenges any Muslim from any part of the world can debate with him and particularly Dr. Zakir Naik but Dr. Zakir Naik is silent on this topic reason best known to him and Allah alone.

May Allah accept your honest quest to serve the Ummah, and reward you abundantly.Ameen.

amar