> Allegation- Muhammad(Sallal lahu Alayhi wa Sallam) Mentally Sick

[Abd al-Muhsin al Hindy]

AsSalaamu alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barkaatuhu,

I need some refuting materials on the Topic of Sallal lahu Alayhi wa Sallam being accused of mental disease and the nature of wahi or revelations were his hallunication ..etc


Can someone help me with the links refuting the claims.

AsSalaamu alaykum.

[Abd al-Muhsin al Hindy]

AsSalaamu alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barkaatuhu,
Flemish psychologist, Dr. Herman Somers accuses Sallal lahu Alayhi wa Sallam of Paranoia Syndrome. (“A different Mohammed”, Hadewych, Antwerp 1993 ) Written in Dutch not Translated in english yet.

There is a good Video lecture by Dr. Zakir on the Issue where he prove Sallal lahu Alayhi wa Sallam innocent but I don't remember the name he gave the lecture in 90's.
So can anyone link me up with good materials.

AsSalaamu alaykum.

[Abd al-Muhsin al Hindy]

AsSalaamu alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barkaatuhu,

Sorry the above post was reposted by mistake.

AsSalaamu alaykum.

[Qatada]

asalaam alaikum


akhi, what i once did is link to a youtube video with the Qur'an, surah Rahman recitation, and english translation of the meaning.


then ask them, is this what an insane person comes up with? or do they come up with muddled words?


then i'd give them many prophecies, and ask them, is this what an insane person comes up with, clear in meaning of future events, or is this what a Messenger of God does?


Then i show them the achievements Prophet Muhammad achieved in his life, and even after it. is this what an insane person can achieve?


if they still persist, tell them that they're insane since they havn't even reached one aspect of his perfection, and he's achieved way more than they ever will.

[Uthmān]

Check out the following videos by 'Abdur-Raheem Green where he addresses the allegations the Muhammad () was a liar and the claim that he () was delusional.

YouTube - Life of The Prophet (pbuh) prt 1/3

YouTube - Life of The Prophet (pbuh) prt 1/3

YouTube - Life of The Prophet (pbuh) prt 2/3

YouTube - Life of The Prophet (pbuh) prt 2/3

YouTube - Life of The Prophet (pbuh) prt 3/3

YouTube - Life of The Prophet (pbuh) prt 3/3

[Umm Sufyaan]

Originally Posted by Abd al-Muhsin al Hindy

AsSalaamu alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barkaatuhu,

I need some refuting materials on the Topic of Sallal lahu Alayhi wa Sallam being accused of mental disease and the nature of wahi or revelations were his hallunication ..etc


Can someone help me with the links refuting the claims.

AsSalaamu alaykum.

the best refutation is to ask for a credible piece of evidence.

[Sampharo]

Originally Posted by Abd al-Muhsin al Hindy

I need some refuting materials on the Topic of Sallal lahu Alayhi wa Sallam being accused of mental disease and the nature of wahi or revelations were his hallunication ..etc

Not that new, Infidels did it in his lifetime. At least accusing him of being a genius poet had more sense; how can an insane person deliver an impeccable quran, and a set of scientific facts that over 1400 years was embraced and adopted by over 1.5 billion people as divine revelation and none were found wrong. Not to mention that the law and rulings that was brought were perfectly coherent and the epitome of justice by all standards.

Some nonsense is beneath the level requiring it to be refuted with evidence or detailed explanations.